Friday, May 23, 2008

Why the independence result was the creation of two countries?

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

Gandhi helped greatly to the independence india is because the British were very abusive in his government…. as a result of this a long time through a peaceful independence could thank the last viceroy of England, Gandhi was very pacific and was called by many religions Muslim, Hindu, Christian, etc..… and he wanted the india pacifica, but what we got was two religions who did not agree on whether and distribution of the two religions, and this is a difference between the two religions.

DAVID FONSECA G.
8B

Anonymous said...

india was governed by the british goverment the british abused the indian people gandhi meke pacific manifestations for the freedom of india but they also have other problems different that the ones thet they have with the british, the indians and the muslims fight each other and the muslims demanded that they have to gave them there own country, when the india eas free of the british they continue the confrontations with the muslims andia was diveded in tow parts, one part was the country of the muslims called pakistan and the other part was india.


Gilberto aleman 8A

Anonymous said...

because the british goverment was present in there treating very bad the people of india, but Gandhi start maikng pacific manifestations for the freedom of the indians, but some of these didnt agrre and they start a conflict.because this conflict, a part of india independence from india creating pakistan,thats why they say the independece of pakistan from india was because of conflict.

Jose Zambrano
8-A

Anonymous said...

The result later to independence that was to create two different countries was because the Muslim leader any it felt sure to the most of the that sable of the era of the that of people of the Indian of the one of that of the religion those that of the and they make traps the Muslims the things any they would change much since those of the they went of the Indian of the types of an of religion of the some of having of the seat against in of seat of the oppression.

juan felipe fuentes 8b

Anonymous said...

because when ghandi independence india the country have to major religions the muslim and hindu, ghandi dont want the two religions in differents places . he think that all the religions have the same god but the muslim leader dont think equal think that the hindu people will goernate and muslim will be supreced. that the reason why all muslim went and form pakistan.

juan david bermudez 8b

Anonymous said...

When the leader of the Muslims know that India get their independence, he take advantage of this situation and put their particular interests like a priority, and require a proper territory and laws, for this reason suggest two options to Gandhi, give Pakistan to the Muslims or have an civil war .Gandhi solve to give Pakistan to the Muslims because he had do many things to get the no-violence and he was not going to let that occur a civil war between Hindus and Muslims. But finally he didn’t attain prevent this conflict that cause many consequences like Gandhi died.
Maria Camila Bobadilla 8B

Anonymous said...

because Gandhi do a pacific manifestation to freedom india but the indians have a conflict with the muslims because the muslims want to be in a country sepparated from the indians so they divide the territory one part for the muslims called pakistan and other part for the indians

JUAN SEBASTIAN VASQUEZ

Anonymous said...

Because before the independence th Hindus and the Muslims had a reason in common to fight for, their independence. But after India finally was a free country they had nothing left to fight for as brothers and they also had to choose their government, so the muslims were woried that they had to live in a country ruled by the Hindus. So they started fighting but Gandhi stoped them with his hunger strike.
So they created Pakistan a Muslim country because thy didn´t wanted to live in a country ruled by Hindus, and they could live in peace.

Maria Margarita Vesga 8B

Anonymous said...

The india was from the british and when the hindus and muslims fight for the independence and when they finally have the independence also apear pakistan, because ghandi dont wants the hindus and the muslism away he want that all live in the same place with peace and thats why it appear two countries as result of the independence pakistan and india.

David Bejarano 8B

Anonymous said...

Gandhi has created muslim countries, because in those countries they can live in peace, they can't do it before because they were fighting for their independence,they begin combats but gandhi end with the strike.
Natalia Plazas 8A

Anonymous said...

sorry muslims and hindu was the 2 countries that creates gandhi.
natalia plazas 8a

Anonymous said...

gandhi decides to separate in two countries becouse they fhigt so much and he dont want that and for that reason he stops that fight whit the independence.
juan sebastian derch 8b

Anonymous said...

Independence gave birth to two countries: India and Pakistan because we had different beliefs, religions (Hindus and Muslims) could not coexist in one country. This will avoid a civil war.

JUAN SEBASTIAN JIMENEZ R. 8A

Anonymous said...

the independence result a creation of two countries that are india and pakistan becouse haves different religions and to avoid the civil war.


christian m. rodriquez 8a

Anonymous said...

Ghandi wants that the two religion leave in peace in the same country, but the musulmans don't think the same so they decide taht there must be two counries one for musulmans and the other for Indus, Pakistan and India.
Juan David Urrego 8B

Anonymous said...

Gandhi create these two countries for which both religions were in conflict.

Juan David Ospina.

Anonymous said...

The two countries were created for gandhi for that both religions were in conflict.


Luis Iván Muñoz.

Anonymous said...

the british people were abusive with india but ghandhi began a new peacefoul way of thinking with a lot of followers, ghandhi got the peace of india and the freedom of india from ingland allways create pakistan.
andrea daniels 8b

Anonymous said...

the creation of pakistan is the result of the conflict between two different religions

andrea daniels 8b

Anonymous said...

Because in India there where to great religions, so, when the Independence occured, another country was created Pakistan.

Sergio Cáceres
8-A

Anonymous said...

Because the fact that so great and influential religions inhabited a same country was so complicated, Gandhi decided to yield part of the territory giving like result the birth of Pakistan.

Catalina Romero Arias 8°A

Anonymous said...

Ghandi started "fighting" for India's independence, and he was supported by muslims, but when he finaly reached his objective, muslims realised that they couldnt live in a hindu country so they decided to start their independence from India, what fanily ended in Pakistan's creation.
Sebastian Pineda 8b

Anonymous said...

Great Betraña tapeworm to be able on the Indian, and begin to arise the (inconformismo) from the town I take that them to face enters they themselves causing who Ganhdi suffered so that cause that its nation (India) did not exist differences of classes, neither religions, nor no type of violence which, I take to a separation of the town (Pakistan - India)

Lina Velandia 8b

Anonymous said...

the result of the indepencedece is the creation of two countries ( india and pakistan) because the diference of the religions

maria camila muñoz

Anonymous said...

becouse Gandhi have two opcions and one of them was a civil war but Gandhi want the no more violence he wanted the end of the violence but gandhi not accept the option of a civil war as this would cause more violence... but gandhi couldn't convince all the people that this way is not the good form to resolve the problems, and always besouse the diference of religions
DIANA GOMEZ BARRETO- 8A :)

Anonymous said...

Gandhi was going property, and almost he was getting the freedom of india but said it would split into india and pakistan and Hindus who was in pakistan will go to india and the Muslims who whent in india have to go to pakistan =D

JuAn PaBlO MeLlAnA 8ºB

Anonymous said...

because there whare two different religions in idia and they`ve got problems so the have to separate into two countries.
SANTIAGO LEON 8ºA

Anonymous said...

The hindus and the muslims fight because after the freedom they have to decide wich of the 2 religions will be the "leader" and they start to fight and to kill so much people, but Bapu (or Gandhi)start the fasting and dont eat nothing so both religions reactionate and leave the fight and create the counties of Pakistan and Muslim.

NICOLAS MÓNICO
8B

Anonymous said...

because before they happen independence Muslims and Hindus had in common reasons for being free to fight for their independence. but since the india is free because it has nothing fight, and who also had to choose their government because the Muslims had to live in a country governed by Hindu

maria camila duque 8a

Anonymous said...

In that time, Pakistan was part of India. The creation of Pakistan as a country is the result of the internal conflict between muslims and hindu people, two of the biggest ethnics groups of India; both wanted the politic power of the country, mainly because of the fear that they had to be wretched by its opponents. So, they decided that the best choose was to create a new country in which muslims could live and the rest of India will belongs from hindu people. That was a good alternative to avoid a civil war. The problem is that they didn't create an internal war, but a war between two countries that were suposed to be join.

Viviana Orduz Samudio

Anonymous said...

First, because before all the conflicts that they had against the English, the Muslims and the Hindus had several conflicts due they different religions and also because when the Hindus obtained the independence they began to think that they were stronger that the Muslims and decided to continue fighting by the independence between religions and due to all strikes and long walks for the peace devised by Gandhi, they ended up dividing itself in two countries.

Vale Rosasco 8A

Anonymous said...

Because Gandhi help a lot to the independence of india and they try to do that all people can stay in peace in india, but muslims and indues have a lot of diferences so they accord to stay in different countries.


Juan David Ospina
8B

daniel said...

gandhi decided the migration and the independence of india an pakistan because he didnt want violence for india.he wants the peace between india and pakistan.

Anonymous said...

Because when India got the independance from the British government in 1947, whith the help of Gandhi ideas of freedom without violence. In India there was a mayor population of Muslims, who were ignore and didn’t had any political representation, so when India got the independance, The muslims also considered created a new and autonomus country for the indian muslims called Pakistan.

JUAN CAMILO CELY
8B

Anonymous said...

in the process of independence that Gandhi impulse, in the negotiations, England said to Gandhi that if England give the liberty to India, India have to separate in two, India and Pakistan, because the religions was different and Pakistan will be to the Muslims and India to the Hindus. Gandhi doesn’t like the condition that England put to them.

DIEGO F. OSPINA VELA 8ºB